Smithtown Student, 16, Arrested With Gun, Knife at High School After Social Media Post

Google Maps aerial view of Smithtown West High School in Smithtown, New York, where a 16-year-old student was arrested after a gun and knife were found in his backpack.

A 16-year-old Smithtown West High School student was arrested Tuesday after a reported conflict between two students led school officials to discover a handgun, bullets and knife in his backpack, according to Suffolk County Police and the Smithtown Central School District.

The Oct. 27 incident began when school administrators were investigating a reported dispute between two students and learned that one of them may have recently posted a photograph of a handgun on social media, Superintendent Mark Secaur said in a letter to the school community.

Administrators contacted Suffolk County Police, and a school resource officer was dispatched to assist, Secaur said. Police also received a 911 call reporting the social media post.

School staff searched the student’s backpack at approximately 1:55 p.m. and discovered a firearm, knife and magazine, police said. Secaur described the handgun as unloaded and said bullets were also recovered.

The student, a 16-year-old Smithtown resident whose name was not released, was arrested without incident, according to the superintendent.

Secaur said the district was not aware of any specific threats directed at students, employees or the school.

“It is important to note that we are still investigating this incident,” Secaur wrote in his Oct. 27 letter.

He said the district could not release additional information because of the continuing investigation and the need to protect student privacy.

Police charged the teenager with second-degree criminal possession of a weapon involving a loaded firearm on school grounds, criminal possession of a weapon on school grounds, criminal possession of a firearm and fourth-degree criminal possession of stolen property involving a firearm.

Although the district described the handgun as unloaded, the police charge specifically references a loaded firearm. Authorities did not explain the difference or provide details about why the stolen property charge was filed.

The teenager was scheduled to appear as an adolescent offender in First District Court Youth Part in Central Islip on Wednesday, Oct. 28. An arraignment outcome was not immediately available.

In addition to the criminal charges, the student will face disciplinary consequences under the district’s Code of Conduct, Secaur said.

The superintendent credited school administrators, security personnel and Suffolk County Police for coordinating their response. He also thanked a student who alerted school officials to the social media post.

“We are also very thankful that a Smithtown student made us aware of the social media post,” Secaur wrote, adding that the information allowed officials to respond quickly.

Secaur acknowledged concerns the discovery could raise among students, parents and school employees.

“The presence of a weapon in our schools is deeply concerning,” he wrote.

He said the district was treating the matter seriously and remained committed to maintaining safe school buildings.

Suffolk County Police Fourth Squad detectives are asking anyone with information about the incident to call 631-854-8451.

Anonymous tips can also be submitted to Suffolk County Crime Stoppers at 1-800-220-TIPS, through the P3 Tips mobile app or online at P3Tips.com. Tipsters may be eligible for a cash reward of up to $5,000 if their information leads to an arrest.

The charges are accusations, and the student is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Photo: Aerial view of Smithtown West High School, where a 16-year-old student was arrested on weapons charges after a firearm and knife were discovered in his backpack on October 27, 2026. (Google Maps)

Find Crime News in Your Town

Explore arrests, investigations and crime reports from communities across Long Island.