An Islip Terrace man was sentenced to 10 years in prison Tuesday for setting fire to an East Islip bar after employees asked him to leave, Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney announced.
Paul Lucia, 61, pleaded guilty in October to arson and related charges stemming from the Nov. 20, 2025, fire at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant. The blaze damaged the building’s exterior awning and kitchen, but no injuries were reported.
According to prosecutors, Lucia was drinking at the bar around 5:30 p.m. when employees asked him to leave after he took a photograph of a staff member.
Lucia drove away in a white Jeep Patriot but returned approximately two hours later carrying a gas can and lighter. Surveillance footage showed him pouring liquid from the gas can near the restaurant’s rear entrance, which was open and occupied by patrons and employees.
Flames erupted shortly afterward as Lucia walked back toward his vehicle. He threw the gas can over a fence onto an adjacent property before driving away, prosecutors said.
A witness provided investigators with the Jeep’s license plate number, which authorities determined had been reported stolen a week earlier.
Detectives from the Suffolk County Police Department’s Arson Squad recovered the gas can from the neighboring property and its cap from a flowerpot outside the bar. A trained canine from the Suffolk County Fire Marshal’s Office detected the presence of ignitable liquids at several locations.
Police located Lucia driving the Jeep on Sunrise Highway the following day and arrested him during a traffic stop. Investigators recovered the lighter used in the fire from inside the vehicle.
On Oct. 13, Lucia pleaded guilty to second-degree arson, third-degree arson and two counts of fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard Horowitz.
On Nov. 17, Horowitz sentenced Lucia to 10 years in prison, followed by five years of post-release supervision.
“What began as a simple request for the defendant to leave the premises escalated into an unwarranted and dangerous act of arson,” Tierney said.
The case was prosecuted by Assistant District Attorneys Sean Lorthioir and Jeremy Waite of the Major Crime Bureau’s Arson Unit.
Photo: Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office.
Find Crime News in Your Town
Explore arrests, investigations and crime reports from communities across Long Island.
