Lakeview Man Charged With Hate Crimes in West Hempstead Synagogue Arson Case, $500K Bail Set

Nassau County Police Department mugshot of Azzm Khan, 29, of Lakeview, charged with arson and criminal mischief as hate crimes in connection with a West Hempstead synagogue fire.

A Lakeview man accused of trying to set fire to a West Hempstead synagogue faces hate crime charges, with bail set at $500,000 cash, according to New York State court records.

Azzm Khan, 29, of Lakeview, was arraigned Oct. 22 in Nassau District Court on five charges, including third-degree arson and third-degree criminal mischief as hate crimes. He pleaded not guilty before Judge Maria Boultadakis.

The court set bail at $500,000 cash, $1.25 million insured bond or $2.5 million partially secured surety bond. Court records do not establish whether Khan has posted bail.

According to Nassau County police, the incident began around 11:30 p.m. Oct. 21, when officers responded to Hall’s Pond Park at 831 Hempstead Ave. after a witness reported seeing a man break the side mirror of a Nassau County Police Department Auxiliary vehicle.

While officers searched for the suspect, another man told them he had seen someone lighting a fire nearby. Police responded to Young Israel of West Hempstead at 630 Hempstead Ave., where they found Khan and a bush that was actively burning.

Investigators determined that Khan had allegedly taken a lawn sign from the area and set it on fire. Police said he tried to shove the burning sign under the synagogue door before placing it in a bush, causing the bush to ignite.

Khan then allegedly returned to the synagogue door and repeatedly kicked it, causing damage. Police also accused him of damaging the auxiliary police vehicle at Hall’s Pond Park.

He was arrested without further incident.

Court records identify the top charge as third-degree arson as a hate crime, a class B felony. Khan also faces third-degree criminal mischief as a hate crime, a class D felony.

The remaining charges include two counts of third-degree criminal mischief, both class E felonies, and fifth-degree arson, a class A misdemeanor.

The Nassau County Police Department’s initial announcement identified the underlying arson and criminal mischief charges but did not specify the hate crime enhancements reflected in the court records.

Khan is represented by court-appointed attorney Mindy Ellen Plotkin.

His next scheduled appearance was listed for Monday, Oct. 26, at 9 a.m. before Judge Anthony William Paradiso in Nassau District Court. The court calendar identifies the appearance as an indictment control proceeding.

Police said the investigation remains ongoing and that there were no known active threats to the community at the time of their announcement.

Photo: Azzm Khan, 29, of Lakeview, pleaded not guilty to arson and criminal mischief charges, including two felony hate crime charges, following an October 21, 2026, incident at a West Hempstead synagogue. Bail was set at $500,000 cash, with bond alternatives. (Nassau County Police Department)

Find Crime News in Your Town

Explore arrests, investigations and crime reports from communities across Long Island.