A former New York State Department of Motor Vehicles supervisor was sentenced to one year in jail for orchestrating a cheating scheme at the Garden City DMV that allowed applicants to obtain commercial driver’s license permits without taking the required exams, Nassau County prosecutors announced Wednesday.
Kanaisha Middleton, 34, was sentenced Oct. 28, 2026, after pleading guilty May 4 to fourth-degree corrupting the government, impairing the integrity of a licensing examination and official misconduct.
According to Nassau County District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly, Middleton directed her sister and enlisted other DMV employees in a scheme that involved impersonating applicants, using disguises and manipulating the agency’s testing procedures.
The investigation began after a supervisor at the Garden City DMV reported suspicions that employees were processing commercial driver’s license (CDL) permit applications for people who had not appeared to take the required examinations.
Between March and September 2023, Middleton’s sister, Jamie Middleton, repeatedly entered the Garden City DMV wearing disguises to take commercial driving permit exams on behalf of other applicants.
Prosecutors said the disguises included oversized clothing, face masks, construction jackets and fake facial hair.
DMV employees allowed Jamie Middleton into the testing room despite discrepancies between her appearance and the identification records of the applicants she was impersonating.
On May 23, 2023, she took exams for two applicants less than five minutes apart while wearing identical clothing.
Those applicants, Rene Sarduy, an employee of the Town of Hempstead Department of Highway, and Omesh Mohan, subsequently visited DMV offices in Springfield Gardens and Bethpage to obtain their temporary permits.
Neither received a full commercial driver’s license. Prosecutors said Mohan failed the required road test.
Investigators determined that Jamie Middleton took nine CDL examinations during the scheme, passing eight of them on behalf of seven applicants. Six of those applicants did not receive full commercial driver’s licenses.
One applicant, James Nurse, a Town of Hempstead Sanitation Department employee, obtained an interim permit at the Massapequa DMV on Aug. 16, 2023, after Jamie Middleton took his exam two days earlier.
Nurse received a full commercial driver’s license on Sept. 28, 2023, and later used the improperly obtained license to operate recycling trucks for the town, prosecutors said.
Jamie Middleton, 36, pleaded guilty May 4 to fourth-degree corrupting the government and eight counts of impairing the integrity of a licensing examination. She was sentenced July 7 to five months in jail and five years of probation.
Several other defendants have also pleaded guilty in connection with the investigation.
Satoya Mitchell, 35, pleaded guilty to impairing the integrity of a government licensing examination, first-degree tampering with public records and official misconduct. She was sentenced April 17 to four years of probation.
Nurse, 43, pleaded guilty to second-degree falsifying business records and was sentenced May 8 to three years of probation.
Sarduy, 45, and Mohan, 43, also pleaded guilty to second-degree falsifying business records. Both received three years of probation.
Another defendant, Tawanna Whitfield, 36, pleaded guilty Jan. 22 and is scheduled for sentencing Nov. 23, 2026.
Donnelly said the scheme compromised a licensing process designed to ensure commercial drivers meet safety requirements.
New York State Inspector General Lucy Lang also condemned the misconduct, saying the defendant had abused a position of public trust and undermined the integrity of the licensing system.
The investigation was conducted with assistance from the New York State Inspector General’s Office and the Department of Motor Vehicles.
The case was prosecuted by members of the Nassau County District Attorney’s Public Corruption Bureau.
Photo: Kanaisha Middleton, 34, was sentenced to one year in jail for orchestrating a commercial driver’s license exam cheating scheme at the Garden City DMV. (Nassau County District Attorney’s Office)
Find Crime News in Your Town
Explore arrests, investigations and crime reports from communities across Long Island.
