Bay Shore Man Faces Sentencing in $25,000 Lowe’s Credit Card Fraud Scheme

Suffolk County Court building in Central Islip, New York, where Anthony Colon is scheduled for sentencing in a Lowe's credit card fraud case.

A Bay Shore man charged in a credit card fraud scheme that allegedly used stolen identities to purchase more than $25,000 in gift cards from Lowe’s stores across Long Island has pleaded guilty to felony grand larceny and is awaiting sentencing.

Anthony J. Colon, 27, pleaded guilty to third-degree grand larceny on Nov. 19, 2025, according to New York State court records. He was one of six people arrested in August 2024 following an investigation into fraudulent credit card accounts opened using the personal information of unsuspecting victims.

More Than $25,000 in Fraudulent Lowe’s Purchases

According to Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney, the scheme operated between October 2023 and February 2024, when the defendants allegedly opened Lowe’s credit card accounts online using the identities of people living throughout the United States.

Prosecutors said the accounts were opened without the victims’ knowledge or permission. The defendants allegedly used those accounts to purchase more than $25,000 worth of gift cards at Lowe’s stores across New York, including at least five locations in Suffolk County.

The stores targeted included locations in Commack, Bay Shore, Farmingdale, Medford and Stony Brook. The amount represents the alleged purchases attributed to the overall scheme, not an amount prosecutors specifically attributed to Colon.

In addition to Colon, authorities arrested Ananda Gabriel of Patchogue, Aameer Waight and Jonathan Lynce of Central Islip, Abilio Sanchez of Huntington Station, and Rashad Provost of Mastic Beach.

Prosecutors also accused Gabriel of using another person’s identity to rent a Patchogue apartment in November 2023 without that individual’s knowledge or consent. That allegation concerned Gabriel and was separate from the charges against Colon.

Arrest and Identity Theft Charges

Colon, who was 25 when the arrests were announced, was initially charged with third-degree grand larceny and first-degree identity theft, both Class D felonies. He also faced misdemeanor charges of attempted petit larceny and attempted third-degree identity theft.

The six defendants were arrested in August 2024 following an investigation by the Suffolk County Police Department’s Financial Crimes Unit, with assistance from other police and prosecutorial units.

At his initial arraignment, Colon was released without monetary bail because the charges were not eligible for bail under New York law. He was placed on supervised release while the case proceeded.

The investigation was prosecuted by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Financial Crimes Bureau.

Guilty Plea, Restitution and Upcoming Sentencing

On Nov. 19, 2025, Colon pleaded guilty to third-degree grand larceny, a Class D felony, before Judge Karen Kerr in Suffolk County Court, according to court records.

The first-degree identity theft and two attempted misdemeanor charges are listed as covered by the plea rather than as separate convictions.

The court also ordered restitution through a civil judgment and placed Colon under interim probation supervision. The publicly available records do not specify the restitution amount or establish whether he has completed the required payments.

On July 27, 2026, the court referred Colon to a problem-solving or alternative court program. His sentencing has subsequently been adjourned several times, most recently on Oct. 29.

Colon is now scheduled to appear for sentencing at 9 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, before Judge Kerr in Suffolk County Court in Central Islip.

The records do not specify an agreed-upon sentence or establish whether his participation in an alternative court program will affect the eventual punishment.

The outcomes of the prosecutions involving the other five defendants were not established in the records reviewed.

Photo: Suffolk County Court in Central Islip, where Anthony Colon is scheduled to be sentenced in connection with a Lowe’s credit card fraud investigation. (Photo credit to be verified)

Find Crime News in Your Town

Explore arrests, investigations and crime reports from communities across Long Island.